In the car, as I'm fighting my way down the M27, it occurred to me in a moment of personal disgust that I had already checked Facebook twice that morning - and it was only 08:45. As if another kick in the gonads of realisation were necessary, it followed that this was not unusual, or indeed different from any other day.
It was probably a privately held moment of self-contempt. I can't imagine any of the other drivers suddenly accepting that they were crack-heads, and wailing into their palms in lament of their addiction. But in truth, I just don't think they're 'there yet'. Many never will be, for the opiate of Facebook is truly its most devastating weapon - attention. Those so hopelessly fed and plugged into to the framework of What Other People Think will never realise what a dreadful form of malnourishment their minds are suffering from.
I suddenly accepted what Facebook has become, for so many legion souls - identity construction. And let me tell you, I've seen some truly spectacular feats of social engineering during my tenure there. It actually disturbed me to realise I'd been doing it myself - a 'sultry' posed picture here, a status update designed to remind people who I am and what I do there....it felt so utterly hollow, untruthful, and....slutty.
I had to make an emergency admission to myself - I was too into it. Not addicted; but too concerned with it. I started to list the reasons I didn't want anything to do with that place anymore, and despite the magnetic lure to resist, stay, and maintain an unhappy status quo, I came up with the following.
- The whole place is a giant ego-stroking platform. Personally, I don't feel the need to post up piffle worded / engineered to make you hold me in a certain esteem.
- You're hungover. Brilliant. No-one else has ever been in this state, and we officially know now that you're a fun person, and that no-one parties quite like you. Cool. You must have lots of friends and be incredibly popular.
- The constant feed of 'apps' - you know, the malevolent code nuggets from shady 'developers' that you have entrusted copious amounts of your own and my personal data to, in the weak, tragic, and desperate hope of finding out who wants to hump you. Try a dating site.
- Having to put up with atrocious standards of written English and 'txt spk', no doubt bolstered by the ADD sugar-rush of Facebook.
- Realising there's a reason you never kept in contact with people in the first place. The past truly is our ultimate delusion.
- Being utterly, completely, resoundingly happy with my life and feeling a complete dearth of caring with regard to impressing anyone on a' social networking' platform. Real apathy in that respect, and it's too bad we can't attempt to relate to each other with as much zeal in the 'real' world.
- Seeing as I don't need to forsake my privacy, the rights to my data, or sell myself to advertisers in exchange for an attention-fix, what am I doing here?
- Some people joined Facebook for one reason - to bolster their ego and meet girls/guys. I'm rather happily settled, and so I sort of feel like a digital peeping tom with a pair of binoculars, enjoying myself rather too much in a virtual bush. The last saving vestiges of Facebook have been connecting me to far away family. Not having that will be a bitter pill to swallow, but one that I'm going to have to chow down on.
- This blurring of the work/home divide is inappropriate and just spells t-r-o-u-b-l-e. I'm sorry, but balls to the convergence of 'modern living'. There's a line, and it shouldn't be crossed. Work discussions do not belong 'on the outside', let alone on public platforms belonging to organisations to whom you have granted IP rights.
- I am not interested in offering you a 'my life is better than yours', 'didn't he/she get fat/thin/sexy' comparison. What does that mean in the scheme of life?
- Forget the General Election - there's a more insidious manifesto to concern yourself with. That of 'Facebook Politics'. It's ruined people (no, really). I, for one, will not concern myself with it.
- Facebook has, bizarrely, become an entity into which people place inordinate trust, as if it were a public service bestowed upon us by fairies. It ain't. Nothing they do is for you - a healthy dose of cynicism and a read of your terms of service will avail you the truth.
If you're using Facebook, for whatever reason, I'm not beating up on you. Quite the opposite, if this is what you need in life, or you're using it for entirely different reasons, then great. Knock yourself out. I made my decision to get out.
Perhaps I'm alone here, but I found that it clouded my mind. I was more concerned with the Peacock-strutting of others that my own mental energies were sapped and dampened by concerning myself with the trivialities of other's lives.
I look forward to a renewed focus, and how this will creatively affect my writing. I remain as enamoured with Twitter as I ever was; the proof was in the pudding when I found myself connected to genuinely like-minded individuals - the sort I would happily share a drink with. The sort that prove the value of true social networking - connecting people that should be connected in the spirit of mutual interest, and not voyeurism.
If you want to, you can read my previous posts relating to Facebook here, here, here and here. Oh yeah, I musn't forget about here, either.
14 knee jerks:
Incidentally, this news story broke on The Reg not long after this blog went up:
http://www.theregister.co.uk/2010/05/14/facebook_trust_dumb/
I wrote a lengthy reply and you walked out on me. As you know, I used your links on Facebook to read your latest blog posts and watch your videos (and I doubt I was the only one) so it's a shame you left. Yes, there really is nothing more dull than reading about what the guy you sat next to in Year 8 Maths had for dinner last night, but every now and then someone writes something funny, clever and interesting and it makes you glad you stuck around. I hope you decide to come back to Facebook, it's not all bad.
you rock manfrom the zoo! lets start duushbag.com :0)
darren roberts like this
I must say, and I hate to say it, having a blog and publishing what is essentially your diary for all to read about your take on the world is equally as self gratifying and ego massaging as Facebook!
I think your previous blog on your hangover and your Funny or Die shoot is essentially replicates your feelings on Point 2 on your list!!!
I completely understand how you feel about the constant dribble put up on fb (myself being guilty for that too!)
But what you put up on fb is so funny and unique (a book could be made of your status updates), and makes so many people, who normally would not have regular access to Robert Milner's hilarious/brilliant/jaw-dropping/surreal sense of humour a tiny window of opportunity to lol (had to be done!)!
What I was going to suggest was that you solve the problem easily....you simply have the 20 or so friends/family that you know and love, remove ever other 'used to know' from your account, and then you will not be privvy to what 'Jon Smith' thought of the fotty results.
I love you so much, and would give my life for you, but I think one has been too hasty, and had punished those that get a little giggle on their lunch break when they read your updates!!
Jen - Of course there's a certain amount good feeling from creating something someone might enjoy. But 'ego massage'? Not sure that's accurate really, I would describe it more as a 'personal vindication'. As I've said before, a certain degree of self-promotion is a neccessary (for me uncomfortable) evil to achieve any remote chance of success. Anyone that's ever tried to make a blog or any media materials work will attest to that. And that's great - I've no issue with others doing that and using platforms like Facebook to help achieve that aim.
What felt off-kilter, as I've said in the blog, is the white-noise stream of bullshit that people post up to try and steer the course of other's perception of them. They build ultimately fictional versions of themselves, that cannot be reconciled with reality. Come on, think about it - don't tell me everything you've ever posted is from the heart. You want to maintain the Jennifer brand and what it represents - and what others have come to expect of you.
There is a BIG difference between promoting your material, and the above. A bloody great gulf, in point of fact.
A friend of mine noted that the origin of this can boiled down to fundamental, human, emotional requirements - the need to be respected, loved, admired etc. And he's right, isn't he? An example of this are the godawful series of 'guess who I worked with today?' type of updates, or pictures that some upload with those ridiculous trout-pout lips and 'angled head'. Typically these will be taken in a club to demonstrate they're out HAVING A GOOD TIME. The same applies for engagement notifications, talk about getting things for houses....it's all crap intended, at some level, to make someone else think you're progressing in life in a way the viewer isn't and therefore they SHOULD FEEL BAD ABOUT THEIR LIVES. To make yourself feel sated, that's a pretty morally bankrupt paradigm if you ask me.
Your suggestion regarding trimming down my 'friends' of course occured to me before anything else...but again, check what I wrote in the blog. Have you ever read the terms of service (the small print) of your Facebook account? It's scary. As a content producer I will not hand over IP property rights to Facebook.
Let me ask you a question? Would you walk over to a stranger in the street, and hand over a portfolio of information about you and friends? Of course not. But Facebook's developer platform allows a level of sharing of my information I, and any sensible person should not feel comfortable with.
'Fine', you might think. 'I don't install any of those applications'. Think again - you'd be disturbed what less discrimate friends have exposed you to through their lack of forethought. Do you want to open yourself up because some hare-brained assocation of yours thinks that all this stuff is provided on a 'kindness of our hearts' basis? It isn't, and our information could be out there anywhere BEYOND Facebook.
The fact that Mark Zuckerburg (Facebook co-creator) was exposed yesterday in the IT press for having referred FB users as 'dumb fucks' for handing their information over in the early days, says all you need to know.
Jen, I didn't know you felt that way about my writing, and it's genuinely lovely to know:) I have on occasions offended you with it, though, right? And that has caused you embarrasment before your friends on Facebook...which again brings me back to the identity construction argument.
Which, in turn, makes me feel assured I have made the right decision.
Vicky - thanks, I really didn't know until I left that people cared much about my various 'outputs'. I've been getting better feedback than ever since I quit! You're absolutely right, every now and then someone would chime in with something great - but it was rare. That particular experience was like rifling through turds with your fingertips on the off-chance someone swallowed a diamond.
Rob - I knew you'd implicitly understand. We'll discuss your douchebag.com concept in detail next Friday :)
Nasstar - Glad you enjoyed it.
I would also add, if anyone liked my status updates so much, just follow me on Twitter.
They haven't gone anywhere.
What you've done is intelligently remove yourself from the Facebook sewage pipe spouting gallons of irrelevant, misinformed and irrelevant shit into the sea of web connected humanity. This comes from the keyboards of people who bored you senseless at work, college and the pub and who now have been given a global megaphone by new media. You're taking the right steps in distancing yourself by going up-country and sitting by a small clear chattering stream with a cool drink and a few of your closest friends - this will bring out the best in you and help you bring more of what we all love to your self-selecting audiences.
Insightful thoughts yourself :)
Thanks for leaving a comment on my blog. That is the only single post on my blog that gets the most hits from around the world, which shows that an unprecedented number of ppl are wisening up to the dark side of the FB phenomenon.
Hmmm I was with you up until you said you still used Twitter, which if anything is even more shallow, pointless and inane than FB. Be a man, get rid of that as well.
I'm glad you understand where I'm coming from, Anon.
I have to disagree with you over Twitter issue. In my experience, one can control exposure to f***wits by virtue of the circle of company kept. Simply put, the people I associate with on Twitter are a little above Farm games and making 'provocative' statements to illicit an 'o babes, wotz wrong LOL' type of reaction.
Facebook will, in some capacity, force you to swallow at least some of this dross. Whereas I can 'tune out' a numpty, and indeed everything I hate about human behaviour on Twitter with comparative ease.
But hey, we all have our opinions, and for the time being I'm staying on Twitter. Thanks for the post!
If I end up leaving Facebook, it won't be because of privacy concerns (DirtyPhoneBook effectively ends privacy regardless of what Facebook does) I'll be leaving Facebook because of the App updates that I don't want or need. Getting a Farmville update for the hundredth time that I don't want or a Mafia wars heist announcement or anything else is just boring. Facebook is just bland nowadays. People go there to wish each other happy birthday and thats about it. It was fun while it lasted, but its not as fun anymore. That's my take on it.
Interesting thoughts, some of which I've had myself. I don't necessarily agree on the superiority of Twitter over FB, or that FB forces me to put up with drek I can avoid on Twitter.
I have very restrictive privacy settings on FB, and "hide" heaps of crud from appearing on my wall, prune apps regularly and restrict what my friends can post about me through their app.s. I've also made several truly good IRL friends, one of whom has been a life-changer, though FB. So I keep a cynical and skeptical eye on FB's never-ending attempts to monetise my data, but will stay for now.
Of my small list of FB friends (85) there are no more than 5 or 6 that I've never met, and the rest are all real friends in the real world. Perhaps this is why the 'conversations' on my wall have less of the ego-stroking, self-gratification seeking that you describe. Not NONE of it, just a lot less of it. Mostly it's friends sharing news with other friends separated only by geography.
I appreciated the overall balance in your post, and it did raise issues I have to keep thinking about, but I think that perhaps it's a little easier to moderate the flow of "personal data out, garbage in" than you suggest.
Post a Comment